• About
  • Archive
  • Contact
The Greening of Gavin
  • Home
  • Our Green Shop
    • Little Green Workshops
  • Green Workshops
    • Cheese Making
    • Soap Making
    • Soy Candle Making
  • eBooks
    • Clay Oven eBook
    • Keep Calm and Make Cheese eBook
  • Podcast
    • TGOG Podcast
    • TGoG Podcast Archive
    • Little Green Cheese
  • Vlog
  • Cheese
  • Green Living
    • Chickens
    • Gardening
    • Soap Making
    • Recipes
    • Climate Change
    • Peak Oil
    • Solar Power
  • Resources

Broad Bean Seed Experiment Results

October 19, 2014 @ 16:23 By Gavin Webber 10 Comments

At the start of the winter growing season I began an experiment.  Would saved broad bean seeds grow better than commercial seed?  I wanted to see if there was any difference.  You can see that my saved seed was a different colour than the commercial seed.  Neither seed had been treated, so I thought that it would be a fair test.

You can read about how I planned the test and sowed the seed back in May 2014.

Saved Seed vs Commercial Seed

Saved Seed (L) vs Commercial Seed (R)

Well the verdict is in.  Drum roll please…

From what I have observed, there is no difference in height or yield of the different plants.  The controls that I put in place were that I watered the bed evenly with the irrigation system.  Both parts of the bed received equal sunlight; about 6 hours a day.  Both batches were fertilised with the same amount of liquid fertiliser, one watering can distributed over each batch.

Broad Bean Seed

The final height of the broad bean patch.

The flowers have stopped appearing, so it is nearly time to harvest the entire bed, which Ben and I will do during next weekend.

I also took a split test photo to see if the bean pods looked any different between the two batches.  Earlier on in the year, I marked where the first batch ended and the second started.

Saved Left, Commercial Right

Saved Left, Commercial Right

Not very scientific, I know, but under the circumstances it was the best I could do.  Each plant had three pods per plant.  I tasted the bean from each type and found no discernible difference.

Fresh Broad Bean Seed

Fresh Broad Bean Seed

Both were absolutely delicious.

An interesting fact is that The Seed Savers’ Handbook states that Broad Bean seed is viable for four years if stored in good conditions.  I will be saving the seed from four plants this year using my usual method.  I cut the plants off near the soil and hang them upside down from the carport rafters with string until they dry out.  Easy as pie.  I then collect the seed from each pod and store in an airtight glass jar in my seed box inside the house.  The seed box is nice and dark.

So there you have it.  Same result with both types.  The best thing about this years’ crop is that there has been no sign of Broad Bean Rust.  All plants are very healthy even though we have had some very strong northerly winds that usually spread the rust fungi.

How many of you planted this wonderful bean this year?  Did you have any issues that I may be able to help out with?  Should me a question via comment, and I will endeavour to answer it.

LIKE WHAT YOU'VE READ OR HEARD?
If so, please join thousands of others who receive exclusive weekly online recaps & tips, and get a FREE COPY of my eBook, The Greening of Gavin - My First Year of Living Sustainably.

 

Will this article help someone you know? If so help them out by sharing now!

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Gardening, Seed saving, vegetables

← Baton Passed Leek and Potato Soup →

About Gavin Webber

Gavin Webber's daily goal is to live a more sustainable lifestyle, in an effort to reduce his family's environmental footprint so we can all make a difference for our children & future generations to come.

Learn more about him here and connect with him on Twitter, Facebook, and Google+.

Comments

  1. rabidlittlehippy says

    October 19, 2014 at 18:33

    Hey Gav, nice experiment. 🙂 I’m eating some of last years frozen broad beans in my dinner tonight actually. Yes, we still have some left. 🙂
    I’ve broad beans in the garden but I have a major pest issue known as a small herd of children who decided that it was faster to go THROUGH the broad bean bed rather than around it. 🙁 Harvest officially decimated. 🙁 On the bright side, the garden bed will have improved from the nitrogen nodules on the roots of the bean plants at least. And I do have either end of that bed to harvest, plus another smaller bed. They’re all podding up now. 🙂

    Reply
    • Gavin Webber says

      October 22, 2014 at 13:15

      Sounds like a bit of an adventure playground at your place Jessie. Glad you will have something to harvest! x

      Reply
      • rabidlittlehippy says

        October 29, 2014 at 09:27

        I might make harvest if Jas stops eating them all raw from the garden!

  2. Deb McSephney says

    October 20, 2014 at 11:01

    Hi Gavin, I can recommend lightly steamed broad beans and silver beet leaves in an omelette with a little goats cheese. I’ve just started harvesting mine, all grown from saved seed from last year. Lots of pods, but I have a problem with wind damage. I usually stake the broad bean bed and pass baling twine through the plants to give them some support. This year I didn’t get around to this and I lost lots of stems in the high winds we had. So the bed looks a bit of a mess… Not beautifully neat like yours.

    Reply
    • Gavin Webber says

      October 22, 2014 at 13:16

      Hi Deb. I used to use twine as well with star pickets in each corner of the bed. Now I figure that because it is quite well sheltered, I leave them to their own devices.

      Reply
  3. Cameron says

    October 20, 2014 at 21:56

    Eating fresh broad beans has to be one of the highlights of the year. I only had one bed planted and in eager anticipation of getting tomatoes in and fruiting by Christmas the whole lot was picked on Friday.

    I recommend eating the smaller ones raw, mashed in a mortar and pestle with garlic, Parmesan and olive oil, eaten on good bread. Heaven. Others were cooked very lightly and tossed through pasta with crispy ham.

    An advantage of picking them a little young is being able to avoid second peeling them.

    Wonderful plants, the tops get eaten around here too. Very good in risotto.

    I grow them in the front yard. Nothing says “I’m a veggie gardener” like big patch of broad beans 🙂

    Reply
    • Gavin Webber says

      October 22, 2014 at 13:17

      I love your recipe suggestion Cameron. Just like a basil pesto but with Broad Beans instead. I will have to try it.

      Reply
  4. Beatrix says

    October 27, 2014 at 03:50

    Gavin I saw an ad for a gardening Ap for iPad on your site somewhere but I can’t find it now. Could you send me the name please. Ta

    Reply
    • Gavin Webber says

      October 27, 2014 at 10:42

      Hi Beatrix. The one I use is Gardenate. Just search for it in the appstore or visit the site

      Reply
  5. Lina says

    May 19, 2019 at 12:41

    Hi Gavin – just wondering if you can blanche and freeze the whole bean with pods and then defrost and use the pods as seed later?
    I can’t find my dried ones and have a frozen packet of beans left that weren’t dried…🤔

    Reply

Comments build lively communities. Let me know your thoughts, but keep it clean and green! Spam is removed instantly. Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search This Blog

Follow my work

About Gavin Webber

About Gavin Webber

An Ordinary Australian Man Who Has A Green Epiphany Whilst Watching A Documentary, Gets a Hybrid Car, Plants A Large Organic Vegetable Garden, Goes Totally Solar, Lowers Consumption, Feeds Composts Bins and Worms, Harvests Rainwater, Raises Chickens, Makes Cheese and Soap, and Eats Locally. All In The Effort To Reduce Our Family's Carbon Footprint So We Can Start Making A Difference For Our Children & Future Generations To Come.

Delve Into the Archives

Visit Our Online Simple Living Shop

Little Green Workshops

Latest Podcast Episode

Subscribe on iTunes

Top Posts & Pages

The Seven Stages Of Change
Strawbridge Family Inspiration
How To Remove Scaly Leg Mites
Building a VegTrug or Two
How To Regrow Spring Onions
Contact
Building a Wicking Bed on Concrete
All Good Things Come to an End
Cob Oven Base Part 2
Clay Oven First Layer

Recent Awards

Recent Awards

Local Green Hero

Categories

Favourite Daily Reads

Debt Free, Cashed Up, and Laughing

The Off-Grid Solar House

Greener Me

The Rogue Ginger

Little Eco Footprints

Down To Earth

Surviving the Suburbs

Little Green Cheese

Eight Acres

The Witches Kitchen

TGOG Readers On-line

Podcast Reviews

  • Always inspiring and entertaining!
    August 4, 2016 by floriographer from Australia

    I've crowed about Gavin's podcast before but I just have to recommend it once again - I love that he shares his learning as well as his successes - it helps the rest of us try try try again! Thanks Gavin!

  • ms
    July 22, 2016 by Ketaea12 from New Zealand

    I really enjoy listening to Gavin, he has a kind lovely voice. He covers some great relevant topics for the everyday greenie. With lots of tips or how to or what not to do. Thanks Gavin, love it!!

  • Well worth your time to tune in
    October 23, 2015 by A Vision Splendid from Australia

    I can highly recommend Gavin’s podcast ! I have followed Gavin’s blog since the very beginning and have loved to see his journey unfold. Gavin has a lovely speaking voice so this podcast is always very easy to listen to. Gavin has a very authentic approach to his green living lifestyle. He shares the ups and downs but always provides motivation and practical steps that we can all implement.

  • very good
    June 28, 2015 by Scared pax from United Kingdom

    This is a great podcast if you want to improve your life in so many aspects and become a more sustainable person. I love the soothing voice, the good pace, and it contains lots of useful information. Recommended!

  • opened my eyes
    May 25, 2015 by Gorn4lyfe from Australia

    A wonderful show!

  • Inspiring
    April 30, 2015 by Alan Whelan from Ireland

    This is a great podcast if you're looking for practical info on saving money by living more sustainably from someone who's made that journey over the last few years. Told in a nice, easy conversational style

  • Green Living, inspiring and practical
    January 8, 2015 by EliseMac from Australia

    Thanks Gav for sharing what has (and hasn't) worked along your journey for living a greener lifestyle. Inspiring and achievable for anyone, I look forward to this podcast weekly.

  • Local food equals less waste
    December 27, 2014 by allotmentadventureswithjean from Australia

    Another brilliant podcast from Gavin Webber encouraging us, and showing us how, to cut down on food miles, growing our own food, and cutting down on food waste. Gavin is a really interesting speaker, showing us how to eat better, growing our own food and how to live more sustainably.

  • Honestly australian
    December 15, 2014 by HodgepodgeOz from Australia

    Fantastic podcast, with a wide variety of well thought and researched topics. Gavin is a honest, forthright pod aster with a genuine interest in helping others get green. Like a day alongside is a day wasted, so too is a week without listening to Gavin. Highly recommended for people starting out, or those in the midst of their new lifestyle. Keep it up Gavin, wish there were more great reviews! Kimberley

  • Morning motivation
    December 8, 2014 by Bunnyworm from Australia

    Gavin has a great passion for living this greener lifestyle that motivates others to do the same. The podcasts are always interesting and informative. :)

  • Passionate Advocate
    October 18, 2014 by BoomOpGirl from Australia

    Gavin's enthusiasm and passion for creating a more sustainable world is nothing short of contagious. Thanks Gav, you are my weekly source of motivation for living a sustainable life! :)

  • Gavin speaks from the heart
    October 13, 2014 by Green gavin from Australia

    Gavin's podcasts are required listening for anyone planning to live a more sustainable life. He doesn't preach, but tells you his story from the heart. You'll laugh, smile, share in his concerns and along the way you'll pick up some great tips on living a simple life.

  • Green thoughts, so well iterated
    October 9, 2014 by Kwasikwami from Australia

    This is a wonderful podcast. Not only does Gavin talk knowledgeably on a range of sustainability topics from gardening tips all the way to the issues facing humanity as a whole, but he does so in such a wonderful voice, it's like listening to my Dad, love it!!

  • Easy listening inspiration on being green
    September 24, 2014 by Broomedy from Australia

    Gav knows how to share his journey to a more sustainable life in a manner that shows just how easy it really is. Not to mention healthier, economically beneficial and generally rewarding. The podcasts are an easy way to absorb Gav's great lifestyle. I recommend to anyone.

  • Thanks Gavin!
    August 31, 2014 by Honeywoodmilk from Australia

    Great practical advice for a greener lifestyle. This podcast is for anybody interested in growing their own food in suburbia, saving electricity, brewing beer, making cheese, all that wonderful business and most of all, saving money! Thanks Gavin, love the podcast mate!

  • Enjoyed those ideas for staying warm
    August 15, 2014 by enduringdragon from United States

    Like you we are having winter here in Chile—brrr! Every bit we can save on heating we will.

  • Green Podcasts
    July 26, 2014 by Carneu from Australia

    Excellent podcasts, which are full of information to help get started on a sustainable lifestyle.

  • Practical ideas and inspiration
    July 19, 2014 by HeathrowHeath from Australia

    I highly recommend Gavin's podcast and blog. Down to earth, entertaining and inspirational. Thank you.

  • Interesting & easy to listen to
    April 27, 2014 by Velocity3 from New Zealand

    Gavin & his guests make this green journey lots of fun.

  • Great green listen
    April 18, 2014 by Obscurenickname from Australia

    Gavin is a great down to earth, tell it like it is aussie with a passion for sustainability and growing food and making cheese

Carbon Offset website

Copyright - Gavin Webber © 2023